About Jeff Michalic

Owner/Managing Broker

Jeff is a professional land broker specializing in investment, tillable, recreational, and hunting properties. He and his wife Buffy have been married for over 26 years and they have three children: Madison, Hunter, and Ben. Growing up in western Indiana, Jeff understands people's connection to land and love of the outdoors. His outdoor activities include bow hunting whitetail deer and turkeys, fishing, land management, and coaching.  Managing property to grow and hunt mature trophy whitetails is Jeff's true passion.  This passion, combined with his real estate knowledge, makes him this area's go-to guy for buying or selling land. Jeff has been a four time Pinnacle Club award winner for sales in the nation and has sold over 15,000 acres from 2018-2021. You can contact Jeff by cell 812-230-4503 , office 765-505-4155 , or email jeffm@mossyoakproperties.com.

View My Listings


I would like to thank Jeff Michalic for his professional expertise and tenacity in handling the sale of our family farm in Indiana. I am also a real estate broker (in Montana), and this sale was one of the most difficult transactions I have ever been involved in. It required two surveys and an attorney to consummate the sale. Jeff stayed on top of every step and reported every progress or setback as each occurred. I highly recommend Jeff to represent you in the sale or purchase of your property.
Owner Vermillion County
Our mother, who passed had farmland in Vigo County, Indiana since the 1950s. We decided to put the land up for sale (188 acres). We searched for realtors and were very happy to come across Jeff Michalic. From our first conversation, Jeff was professional, knowledgeable, honest, and personable. And in spite of the land sitting idle for a few years with no crops and having limited access, Jeff managed to find perspective clients. He even recommended a local farmer, which we hired to clear the land and plant crops. After about a year of not much interest, Jeff was open to discussing a new strategy and made suggestions on how to lower the price and entice a variety of potential buyers. It included considering wetland programs, and leasing part of the land for hunting and fishing. This strategy worked, and we recently negotiated a cash offer with a buyer. For these reasons, I highly recommend Jeff as a realtor who specializes in farmland on the IL and IN sides.
Seller Vigo County Indiana

Land for Sale by Jeff Michalic

Clay County, IN
Clay County 312 is a mixed use residential, recreational, timberland located near Brazil, IN 47881. This property truly does have it all and then some. To start, the property has 2 homes. Home number 1 was built in 1997. It has 2464 square feet with ...
312± Acres
Vigo County, IN
The Honey Creek 85 is located in Vigo County, Indiana just south of Terre Haute. This property is mostly wooded with a few open areas. The wooded ground has a lot a variety with areas of mature forest along Honey Creek, areas of former CRP plantings ...
84.73± Acres
New Listing
Parke County, IN
2093 W. Tickridge Road is a 33 acre residential property located in southwestern Parke County, Indiana. This property features a log home that originated in 1856. It was moved to the property and rebuilt in 1970. In 1982, it underwent a major renovat...
33± Acres
New Listing
Parke County, IN
The Leatherwood 33 is an all wooded property located in Parke County just west of Rockville, Indiana. This parcel is just west of Cooke Road and has a deeded easement off of County Road 100 S. This area has a number of new homes and offers country li...
32.96± Acres
New Listing
Parke County, IN
176 Middle Street is country living with in-town convenience. This property is only 2 blocks from Main Street in Rosedale but feels like it's miles away. The home is a 1620 sq ft, manufactured home built in 2003. It has 3 bedrooms and 2 and half bath...
6± Acres
Under Contract
Vermillion County, IN
The Little Vermillion 76 is located just north of Cayuga, Indiana and less than 1.5 miles from the former Newport Chemical Depot. This area is well known for producing some great whitetails year after year. This property offers a little bit of everyt...
76± Acres

Contact Jeff Michalic

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.